Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Even Beethoven Protested Through His Music!

Thankfully, I had to do a paper topic about Beethoven and his views on Napoleon and the Napoleonic Wars last semester. Beethoven was very into politics and had very strong views about society around him. Beethoven lived in Vienna during the time that Napoleon came and occupied it. The Eroica Symphony is a very politically driven piece. There have been many disputes about who the heroic character in the symphony is. It is widely accepted among musicologists that Napoleon was the figure about whom Beethoven was writing. In 1803, Beethoven considered dedicating the Erocia Symphony to Napoleon. There is a legend that Beethoven became so enraged when Napoleon crowned himself Emperor that he withdrew his dedication. However, there are some time discrepancies with this legend. Really, it probably had more to do with satisfying patrons. It was all about the money. In fact, it seemed that Beethoven really admired the grand, heroic figure of Napoleon. Beethoven was quoted on saying this about Napoleon's death in 1821, " I have already written a piece for that catastrophe." Beethoven's Ninth Symphony is also a political piece. It was political to Beethoven (he wanted to make a statement about ideal power in response to all the politics that were going on in Europe). The author of the book Beethoven's Ninth: A Political History suggests that there was also an undertone of nationality and a call for freedom from tyranny in the piece. However, the Ninth Symphony has been used in some interesting political ways throughout the years. For instance, Hitler had the piece played frequently in concentration camps and on his birthday. The piece was also played when the Berlin Wall fell in 1989. These are just some of the interesting and sometimes odd uses of this piece when one keeps in mind why the composer wrote it in the first place.

5 comments:

  1. The performance practice of Beethoven's Ninth Symphony is something that I just recently found out about myself, and I'm glad to see that you wrote about it! Isn't it funny how it's usually the classic instrumental music that is the hardest to interpret? It could be because there are no words from which to grasp any sort of main idea, but ethnomusicologists have to known that there was some underlying emotion in his music, but what it is we might never really know.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The intense usage of Beethoven's 9th symphony was unknown to me. The 9th symphony is extremely emotional and dramatic, but I am curious as to why Hitler chose that particular piece. However, there is no doubt in my mind that classical instrumental music can be utilized to extrude deep emotions from the powerful harmonic overlays. For me, Beethoven's symphonies have much more impact than famous singers.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I did a report once on the Berlin wall, but it was news to me that Beethoven's Ninth Symphony was played then. I think Beethoven was right in thinking of Napoleon as a great man, but he did cause a lot of bad things to happen when he declared himself emperor. (My grandmother is a great collector of Napoleon antiques and books on him. She can get very worked up when people start talking about him in a negative way.)The way I always thought about Napoleon is probably pretty favorable because without him needing money for his wars Louisiana would not have been sold to the United States when it was and I probably would have grown up speaking French or Cajun French. (Did you know that they have Napoleon's death mask in the Cabildo? I think it might be one of many, but I'm not quite sure.)
    I really enjoyed your blog and am very happy now that I have found a way to post a comment on it... have a lovely evening!
    I really enjoyed this blog.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is interesting. In fact, when I was typing my entry I found a blog entry with similar information on B9.

    http://www.democracycellproject.net/blog/archives/2006/02/music_as_propog.html

    ReplyDelete
  5. It's interesting how music without words/lyrics has the ability to create certain emotions (e.g. sadness, happiness, bravery, heroism). It's also intriguing how through a piece's distinct characteristic, one could associate it with a person/an event.

    ReplyDelete